{"schema_version":2,"canonical_url":"https://asc.understandingaccounting.org/asc/430/926/","source":"FASB Accounting Standards Codification, Basic View","usage":"Study and research edition. Verify current requirements with the official source. Summaries, enrichment, and tags are machine-generated study aids. Paragraph html preserves source markup; snippet is abbreviated. Pending content is not necessarily effective.","number":"430-926","topic":"430","title":"Entertainment—Films","area":"Liabilities","paragraphs":6,"summary":"This subtopic formerly addressed deferred revenue (advances and license fees received before recognition) for entertainment—films entities. Every substantive paragraph in Sections 05, 15, and 25 was superseded by ASU 2014-09 (the revenue standard), so the subtopic contains no remaining guidance. Film-related contract liabilities are now accounted for under ASC 606 and ASC 926-605/926-10 as amended.","concepts":["deferred revenue","contract liability","film licensing","superseded guidance","advances from customers","revenue recognition transition"],"categories":["Revenue","Industry-specific","Transition and effective dates","Presentation"],"level":"intermediate","topic_title":"Deferred Revenue","sections":[{"number":"00","label":"00 Status","anchor":"00-status","is_sec":false,"groups":[{"block":null,"heading":null,"paragraphs":[{"citation":"430-926-00-1","para":"00-1","html":"<div class=\"asc-body\"><div class=\"norm-text\">The following table identifies the changes made to this Subtopic.</div> <div class=\"norm-text\"> <table class=\"asc-table\" id=\"SL51574553-203200\"> <tr> <td class=\"entry\"> <strong class=\"ph b\">Paragraph</strong> </td> <td class=\"entry\"> <strong class=\"ph b\">Action</strong> </td> <td class=\"entry\"> <strong class=\"ph b\">Accounting Standards Update</strong> </td> <td class=\"entry\"> <strong class=\"ph b\">Date</strong> </td> </tr> <tr> <td class=\"entry\"></td> <td class=\"entry\"></td> <td class=\"entry\"></td> <td class=\"entry\"></td> </tr> <tr> <td class=\"entry\"> <strong class=\"ph b\">Revenue</strong> </td> <td class=\"entry\">Superseded</td> <td class=\"entry\"> <a href=\"/updates/asu-2014-09/\" class=\"xref\">Accounting Standards Update No. 2014-09</a> </td> <td class=\"entry\">05/28/2014</td> </tr> <tr> <td class=\"entry\"></td> <td class=\"entry\"></td> <td class=\"entry\"></td> <td class=\"entry\"></td> </tr> <tr> <td class=\"entry\"> <a href=\"/asc/430/926/#430-926-05-1\" class=\"xref\">926-430-05-1</a> </td> <td class=\"entry\">Superseded</td> <td class=\"entry\"> <a href=\"/updates/asu-2014-09/\" class=\"xref\">Accounting Standards Update No. 2014-09</a> </td> <td class=\"entry\">05/28/2014</td> </tr> <tr> <td class=\"entry\"> <a href=\"/asc/430/926/#430-926-15-1\" class=\"xref\">926-430-15-1</a> </td> <td class=\"entry\">Superseded</td> <td class=\"entry\"> <a href=\"/updates/asu-2014-09/\" class=\"xref\">Accounting Standards Update No. 2014-09</a> </td> <td class=\"entry\">05/28/2014</td> </tr> <tr> <td class=\"entry\"> <div class=\"xref-range displayInline\"><a href=\"/asc/430/926/#430-926-25-1\" class=\"xref\">926-430-25-1 through 25-3</a></div> </td> <td class=\"entry\">Superseded</td> <td class=\"entry\"> <a href=\"/updates/asu-2014-09/\" class=\"xref\">Accounting Standards Update No. 2014-09</a> </td> <td class=\"entry\">05/28/2014</td> </tr> </table> </div> </div>","snippet":"The following table identifies the changes made to this Subtopic.\nParagraph | Action | Accounting Standards Update | Date |\n| | | |\nRevenue | Superseded | Accounting Standards Update No. 2014-09 | 05/28/2014 |\n| | | |\n92…","pending":false,"provenance":{"source_url":"https://asc.fasb.org/","snapshot_version":"sha256:15aea8165dff9f5ae47d9484f8470588b13b307f56e1d50801bf4d85ec190e3f","record_version":"sha256:11c426d1c57fa572bcb6432c8cd1a2e22019c3d92b5474eac4a5ad8c0be63e46","downloaded_from":"2026-09-10T00:24:00.334Z","last_downloaded_at":"2026-09-10T00:24:00.334Z","date_scope":"source_page","effective_as_of":null,"effective_as_of_status":"Not established by retrieval timestamps","source_key":"1943274/2147477467","source_sha256":"81fad31a876db59b24eec9a29c572c601500ab34702ac3b0869598eef121ac9a"}}],"provenance":{"source_url":"https://asc.fasb.org/","snapshot_version":"sha256:15aea8165dff9f5ae47d9484f8470588b13b307f56e1d50801bf4d85ec190e3f","record_version":"sha256:48f0838aba00bdc6d7d0add2b304322f9972cd71663b9eb91f64def836edd653","downloaded_from":"2026-09-10T00:24:00.334Z","last_downloaded_at":"2026-09-10T00:24:00.334Z","date_scope":"source_page","effective_as_of":null,"effective_as_of_status":"Not established by retrieval timestamps","source_key":"1943274/2147477467","source_sha256":"81fad31a876db59b24eec9a29c572c601500ab34702ac3b0869598eef121ac9a"}}],"provenance":{"source_url":"https://asc.fasb.org/","snapshot_version":"sha256:15aea8165dff9f5ae47d9484f8470588b13b307f56e1d50801bf4d85ec190e3f","record_version":"sha256:23eb5d5c123136c6e30acf1c3177cfaf7ddfd591a70889a3a847fca24d310268","downloaded_from":"2026-09-10T00:24:00.334Z","last_downloaded_at":"2026-09-10T00:24:00.334Z","date_scope":"source_page","effective_as_of":null,"effective_as_of_status":"Not established by retrieval timestamps","source_key":"1943274/2147477467","source_sha256":"81fad31a876db59b24eec9a29c572c601500ab34702ac3b0869598eef121ac9a"}},{"number":"05","label":"05 Overview and Background","anchor":"05-overview-and-background","is_sec":false,"groups":[{"block":null,"heading":null,"paragraphs":[{"citation":"430-926-05-1","para":"05-1","html":"<div class=\"asc-body\"><div class=\"norm-text\"><a href=\"/updates/asu-2014-09/\" class=\"xref\">Paragraph superseded by Accounting Standards Update No. 2014-09</a>.</div></div>","snippet":"Paragraph superseded by Accounting Standards Update No. 2014-09.","pending":false,"provenance":{"source_url":"https://asc.fasb.org/","snapshot_version":"sha256:15aea8165dff9f5ae47d9484f8470588b13b307f56e1d50801bf4d85ec190e3f","record_version":"sha256:647029f72180de89ec76e5019a7beebc88172e3e0cc18392cd5149620be49374","downloaded_from":"2026-09-10T00:24:03.274Z","last_downloaded_at":"2026-09-10T00:24:03.274Z","date_scope":"source_page","effective_as_of":null,"effective_as_of_status":"Not established by retrieval timestamps","source_key":"1943274/2147478371","source_sha256":"472ceeb8f7f36c3b110d6697dd2c02ef026f5e529202bfb9bed351bc26ed76eb"}}],"provenance":{"source_url":"https://asc.fasb.org/","snapshot_version":"sha256:15aea8165dff9f5ae47d9484f8470588b13b307f56e1d50801bf4d85ec190e3f","record_version":"sha256:54ef8940f3c18d521514342d9d86313acafad0db9b14ef6d82e1eaeefd2f2af9","downloaded_from":"2026-09-10T00:24:03.274Z","last_downloaded_at":"2026-09-10T00:24:03.274Z","date_scope":"source_page","effective_as_of":null,"effective_as_of_status":"Not established by retrieval timestamps","source_key":"1943274/2147478371","source_sha256":"472ceeb8f7f36c3b110d6697dd2c02ef026f5e529202bfb9bed351bc26ed76eb"}}],"provenance":{"source_url":"https://asc.fasb.org/","snapshot_version":"sha256:15aea8165dff9f5ae47d9484f8470588b13b307f56e1d50801bf4d85ec190e3f","record_version":"sha256:f663bdcdccf5f038e9e0579eeec8ad8aea9f08e7e256976e9d8490816a53d84d","downloaded_from":"2026-09-10T00:24:03.274Z","last_downloaded_at":"2026-09-10T00:24:03.274Z","date_scope":"source_page","effective_as_of":null,"effective_as_of_status":"Not established by retrieval timestamps","source_key":"1943274/2147478371","source_sha256":"472ceeb8f7f36c3b110d6697dd2c02ef026f5e529202bfb9bed351bc26ed76eb"}},{"number":"15","label":"15 Scope and Scope Exceptions","anchor":"15-scope-and-scope-exceptions","is_sec":false,"groups":[{"block":null,"heading":null,"paragraphs":[{"citation":"430-926-15-1","para":"15-1","html":"<div class=\"asc-body\"><div class=\"norm-text\"><a href=\"/updates/asu-2014-09/\" class=\"xref\">Paragraph superseded by Accounting Standards Update No. 2014-09</a>.</div></div>","snippet":"Paragraph superseded by Accounting Standards Update No. 2014-09.","pending":false,"provenance":{"source_url":"https://asc.fasb.org/","snapshot_version":"sha256:15aea8165dff9f5ae47d9484f8470588b13b307f56e1d50801bf4d85ec190e3f","record_version":"sha256:666111c929a49a84a678a5087d8d2fdfe9d78f09799fbe235b5b16a6d724ac7b","downloaded_from":"2026-09-10T00:24:06.503Z","last_downloaded_at":"2026-09-10T00:24:06.503Z","date_scope":"source_page","effective_as_of":null,"effective_as_of_status":"Not established by retrieval timestamps","source_key":"1943274/2147477193","source_sha256":"357d367b8a02fe0e70d6e5613e0ef24367d0b5c74efbaa40b2afc035908caab0"}}],"provenance":{"source_url":"https://asc.fasb.org/","snapshot_version":"sha256:15aea8165dff9f5ae47d9484f8470588b13b307f56e1d50801bf4d85ec190e3f","record_version":"sha256:a2aeda1ba985745091b575ed85a15d6eb7fd3e7028c7c1dee45d227293aa75c1","downloaded_from":"2026-09-10T00:24:06.503Z","last_downloaded_at":"2026-09-10T00:24:06.503Z","date_scope":"source_page","effective_as_of":null,"effective_as_of_status":"Not established by retrieval timestamps","source_key":"1943274/2147477193","source_sha256":"357d367b8a02fe0e70d6e5613e0ef24367d0b5c74efbaa40b2afc035908caab0"}}],"provenance":{"source_url":"https://asc.fasb.org/","snapshot_version":"sha256:15aea8165dff9f5ae47d9484f8470588b13b307f56e1d50801bf4d85ec190e3f","record_version":"sha256:c74c9f4fae428872b20cc51c41ab25c490192235487e5d985a6e1c60b5c12569","downloaded_from":"2026-09-10T00:24:06.503Z","last_downloaded_at":"2026-09-10T00:24:06.503Z","date_scope":"source_page","effective_as_of":null,"effective_as_of_status":"Not established by retrieval timestamps","source_key":"1943274/2147477193","source_sha256":"357d367b8a02fe0e70d6e5613e0ef24367d0b5c74efbaa40b2afc035908caab0"}},{"number":"20","label":"20 Glossary","anchor":"20-glossary","is_sec":false,"groups":[],"provenance":{"source_url":"https://asc.fasb.org/","snapshot_version":"sha256:15aea8165dff9f5ae47d9484f8470588b13b307f56e1d50801bf4d85ec190e3f","record_version":"sha256:bf80daccfc71ebb0d1c9b1bcb06f8014d57392beb32471eb856fa5712af96202","downloaded_from":"2026-09-10T00:24:09.019Z","last_downloaded_at":"2026-09-10T00:24:09.019Z","date_scope":"source_page","effective_as_of":null,"effective_as_of_status":"Not established by retrieval timestamps","source_key":"1943274/2147477827","source_sha256":"6c0fd5a48e23ee0c417cddf02f5ff4e1f693c90f33a9c99b0f731119edc9b777"}},{"number":"25","label":"25 Recognition","anchor":"25-recognition","is_sec":false,"groups":[{"block":null,"heading":null,"paragraphs":[{"citation":"430-926-25-1","para":"25-1","html":"<div class=\"asc-body\"><div class=\"norm-text\"><a href=\"/updates/asu-2014-09/\" class=\"xref\">Paragraph superseded by Accounting Standards Update No. 2014-09</a>.</div></div>","snippet":"Paragraph superseded by Accounting Standards Update No. 2014-09.","pending":false,"provenance":{"source_url":"https://asc.fasb.org/","snapshot_version":"sha256:15aea8165dff9f5ae47d9484f8470588b13b307f56e1d50801bf4d85ec190e3f","record_version":"sha256:1523ebd4a8488c80dfed74024ff5cc5bd720c139ad1e03b309ab80ef3df99d3f","downloaded_from":"2026-09-10T00:24:12.601Z","last_downloaded_at":"2026-09-10T00:24:12.601Z","date_scope":"source_page","effective_as_of":null,"effective_as_of_status":"Not established by retrieval timestamps","source_key":"1943274/2147478453","source_sha256":"379dc9f21ece0435e73ad34551ce3d332f28757cc8218654e37c5689abe6c5b1"}},{"citation":"430-926-25-2","para":"25-2","html":"<div class=\"asc-body\"><div class=\"norm-text\"><a href=\"/updates/asu-2014-09/\" class=\"xref\">Paragraph superseded by Accounting Standards Update No. 2014-09</a>.</div></div>","snippet":"Paragraph superseded by Accounting Standards Update No. 2014-09.","pending":false,"provenance":{"source_url":"https://asc.fasb.org/","snapshot_version":"sha256:15aea8165dff9f5ae47d9484f8470588b13b307f56e1d50801bf4d85ec190e3f","record_version":"sha256:c3af08340e76f9542ec888edeb43a315fbe1bcdbbf9e8e9633825f9066626794","downloaded_from":"2026-09-10T00:24:12.601Z","last_downloaded_at":"2026-09-10T00:24:12.601Z","date_scope":"source_page","effective_as_of":null,"effective_as_of_status":"Not established by retrieval timestamps","source_key":"1943274/2147478453","source_sha256":"379dc9f21ece0435e73ad34551ce3d332f28757cc8218654e37c5689abe6c5b1"}},{"citation":"430-926-25-3","para":"25-3","html":"<div class=\"asc-body\"><div class=\"norm-text\"><a href=\"/updates/asu-2014-09/\" class=\"xref\">Paragraph superseded by Accounting Standards Update No. 2014-09</a>.</div></div>","snippet":"Paragraph superseded by Accounting Standards Update No. 2014-09.","pending":false,"provenance":{"source_url":"https://asc.fasb.org/","snapshot_version":"sha256:15aea8165dff9f5ae47d9484f8470588b13b307f56e1d50801bf4d85ec190e3f","record_version":"sha256:c058096d0b352afc76ec69d4b476be3418597021e66eeba3aae3fcf161d7e4cb","downloaded_from":"2026-09-10T00:24:12.601Z","last_downloaded_at":"2026-09-10T00:24:12.601Z","date_scope":"source_page","effective_as_of":null,"effective_as_of_status":"Not established by retrieval timestamps","source_key":"1943274/2147478453","source_sha256":"379dc9f21ece0435e73ad34551ce3d332f28757cc8218654e37c5689abe6c5b1"}}],"provenance":{"source_url":"https://asc.fasb.org/","snapshot_version":"sha256:15aea8165dff9f5ae47d9484f8470588b13b307f56e1d50801bf4d85ec190e3f","record_version":"sha256:1d0bfa3e626851d5ea60dea76a230805ea18f8b061bdbdb495c9f2e6a591d9db","downloaded_from":"2026-09-10T00:24:12.601Z","last_downloaded_at":"2026-09-10T00:24:12.601Z","date_scope":"source_page","effective_as_of":null,"effective_as_of_status":"Not established by retrieval timestamps","source_key":"1943274/2147478453","source_sha256":"379dc9f21ece0435e73ad34551ce3d332f28757cc8218654e37c5689abe6c5b1"}}],"provenance":{"source_url":"https://asc.fasb.org/","snapshot_version":"sha256:15aea8165dff9f5ae47d9484f8470588b13b307f56e1d50801bf4d85ec190e3f","record_version":"sha256:124dd00b3af5f67e96c58f9975bb025c586417790d95b1eb7ca51fc4d50c9116","downloaded_from":"2026-09-10T00:24:12.601Z","last_downloaded_at":"2026-09-10T00:24:12.601Z","date_scope":"source_page","effective_as_of":null,"effective_as_of_status":"Not established by retrieval timestamps","source_key":"1943274/2147478453","source_sha256":"379dc9f21ece0435e73ad34551ce3d332f28757cc8218654e37c5689abe6c5b1"}}],"enrichment":{"summary":"This subtopic formerly addressed deferred revenue (advances and license fees received before recognition) for entertainment—films entities. Every substantive paragraph in Sections 05, 15, and 25 was superseded by ASU 2014-09 (the revenue standard), so the subtopic contains no remaining guidance. Film-related contract liabilities are now accounted for under ASC 606 and ASC 926-605/926-10 as amended.","key_points":["All content in this subtopic (430-926-05-1, 430-926-15-1, and 430-926-25-1 through 25-3) was superseded by Accounting Standards Update No. 2014-09.","No recognition, measurement, or disclosure requirements remain in ASC 430-926; it is a shell retained for cross-reference and transition purposes.","Amounts a film entity receives before satisfying its performance obligations are now presented as contract liabilities under ASC 606-10-45-1 through 45-2 rather than under legacy film deferred revenue guidance.","Entities applying pre-ASU 2014-09 guidance during transition would look to the superseded text; entities under Topic 606 must not apply it."],"categories":["Revenue","Industry-specific","Transition and effective dates","Presentation"],"audience_level":"intermediate","student_note":"The practical lesson is that ASU 2014-09 wiped out industry-specific deferred revenue rules for films; the common mistake is citing ASC 430-926 as live authority when the answer now lies in ASC 606's contract liability model.","related_topics":["606","926-605","926-10","430-10","340-40"],"key_concepts":["deferred revenue","contract liability","film licensing","superseded guidance","advances from customers","revenue recognition transition"],"provenance":{"source_url":"https://asc.fasb.org/","snapshot_version":"sha256:15aea8165dff9f5ae47d9484f8470588b13b307f56e1d50801bf4d85ec190e3f","record_version":"sha256:3d50d03fb51a9ba1da3abe1e981bf1d43c6486e034c09fac275c79b280cd3290","downloaded_from":"2026-09-10T00:24:00.334Z","last_downloaded_at":"2026-09-10T00:24:12.601Z","date_scope":"source_page_range","effective_as_of":null,"effective_as_of_status":"Not established by retrieval timestamps"}},"related":[{"number":"430-928","title":"Entertainment—Music","topic_title":"Deferred Revenue","score":0.9392,"provenance":{"source_url":"https://asc.fasb.org/","snapshot_version":"sha256:15aea8165dff9f5ae47d9484f8470588b13b307f56e1d50801bf4d85ec190e3f","record_version":"sha256:3ad388151f4199ec721c7f7ae689f01fd31b66fa0696a2c38e3084b058aeb629","downloaded_from":"2026-09-10T00:24:14.561Z","last_downloaded_at":"2026-09-10T00:24:22.885Z","date_scope":"source_page_range","effective_as_of":null,"effective_as_of_status":"Not established by retrieval timestamps"}},{"number":"430-922","title":"Entertainment—Cable Television","topic_title":"Deferred Revenue","score":0.9086,"provenance":{"source_url":"https://asc.fasb.org/","snapshot_version":"sha256:15aea8165dff9f5ae47d9484f8470588b13b307f56e1d50801bf4d85ec190e3f","record_version":"sha256:3067a56fb0c6b1f9fad6ec9affdef83a212eeb4891148b10ed5e2b6e3defff8f","downloaded_from":"2026-09-10T00:23:40.791Z","last_downloaded_at":"2026-09-10T00:23:57.093Z","date_scope":"source_page_range","effective_as_of":null,"effective_as_of_status":"Not established by retrieval timestamps"}},{"number":"605-926","title":"Entertainment—Films","topic_title":"Revenue Recognition","score":0.8616,"provenance":{"source_url":"https://asc.fasb.org/","snapshot_version":"sha256:15aea8165dff9f5ae47d9484f8470588b13b307f56e1d50801bf4d85ec190e3f","record_version":"sha256:18e6f871ccd7fc5d9ac0c3f289d53a52c35ab8bbce858d4a3d655bc680e9cd99","downloaded_from":"2026-09-10T00:47:51.885Z","last_downloaded_at":"2026-09-10T00:48:09.300Z","date_scope":"source_page_range","effective_as_of":null,"effective_as_of_status":"Not established by retrieval timestamps"}},{"number":"855-926","title":"Entertainment—Films","topic_title":"Subsequent Events","score":0.8196,"provenance":{"source_url":"https://asc.fasb.org/","snapshot_version":"sha256:15aea8165dff9f5ae47d9484f8470588b13b307f56e1d50801bf4d85ec190e3f","record_version":"sha256:be63c1ed092adcf9220ef1c3a84d8f93b32b6aec1d09dea12b162bd7b7226e11","downloaded_from":"2026-09-10T02:05:12.680Z","last_downloaded_at":"2026-09-10T02:05:23.939Z","date_scope":"source_page_range","effective_as_of":null,"effective_as_of_status":"Not established by retrieval timestamps"}},{"number":"605-928","title":"Entertainment—Music","topic_title":"Revenue Recognition","score":0.816,"provenance":{"source_url":"https://asc.fasb.org/","snapshot_version":"sha256:15aea8165dff9f5ae47d9484f8470588b13b307f56e1d50801bf4d85ec190e3f","record_version":"sha256:41c52740a15822c53ba7f3ddbb7d5b707f7a00b5ce97da19553584913f306504","downloaded_from":"2026-09-10T00:48:12.626Z","last_downloaded_at":"2026-09-10T00:48:29.629Z","date_scope":"source_page_range","effective_as_of":null,"effective_as_of_status":"Not established by retrieval timestamps"}},{"number":"845-926","title":"Entertainment—Films","topic_title":"Nonmonetary Transactions","score":0.8157,"provenance":{"source_url":"https://asc.fasb.org/","snapshot_version":"sha256:15aea8165dff9f5ae47d9484f8470588b13b307f56e1d50801bf4d85ec190e3f","record_version":"sha256:520460a173449b1d2d9fa5c23eb028bc95d5faa9c932a4974f2097abb64a4d06","downloaded_from":"2026-09-10T02:00:32.051Z","last_downloaded_at":"2026-09-10T02:00:40.674Z","date_scope":"source_page_range","effective_as_of":null,"effective_as_of_status":"Not established by retrieval timestamps"}}],"prev":{"number":"430-922","title":"Entertainment—Cable Television","topic_title":"Deferred Revenue","provenance":{"source_url":"https://asc.fasb.org/","snapshot_version":"sha256:15aea8165dff9f5ae47d9484f8470588b13b307f56e1d50801bf4d85ec190e3f","record_version":"sha256:8823034e5a0a6ca8bb686e33091265ff78401132c50f1ea991e197d20ec3f3ea","downloaded_from":"2026-09-10T00:23:40.791Z","last_downloaded_at":"2026-09-10T00:23:57.093Z","date_scope":"source_page_range","effective_as_of":null,"effective_as_of_status":"Not established by retrieval timestamps"}},"next":{"number":"430-928","title":"Entertainment—Music","topic_title":"Deferred Revenue","provenance":{"source_url":"https://asc.fasb.org/","snapshot_version":"sha256:15aea8165dff9f5ae47d9484f8470588b13b307f56e1d50801bf4d85ec190e3f","record_version":"sha256:4adfcafe19d12cd396648fe8ede73ed81d410d04c2382462fc874b3e1483940f","downloaded_from":"2026-09-10T00:24:14.561Z","last_downloaded_at":"2026-09-10T00:24:22.885Z","date_scope":"source_page_range","effective_as_of":null,"effective_as_of_status":"Not established by retrieval timestamps"}},"provenance":{"source_url":"https://asc.fasb.org/","snapshot_version":"sha256:15aea8165dff9f5ae47d9484f8470588b13b307f56e1d50801bf4d85ec190e3f","record_version":"sha256:e3a8aea4277d5d13bee35092205f9db2fe1a8113bd8c885e450421a90f8ab450","downloaded_from":"2026-09-10T00:24:00.334Z","last_downloaded_at":"2026-09-10T00:24:12.601Z","date_scope":"source_page_range","effective_as_of":null,"effective_as_of_status":"Not established by retrieval timestamps"}}