ASC 944-20
Insurance Activities
944 Financial Services—Insurance
Source downloaded: .Record version 0e1c1418b9d8. Effective date must be checked in the source.
ASC 944-20 sets the framework for insurance accounting based on the nature of the contract rather than the type of entity: contracts are classified at inception as short-duration (fixed short coverage period, insurer can cancel or reprice each period, 944-20-15-7) or long-duration (not subject to unilateral change, services rendered over an extended period, 944-20-15-10), with sub-models for traditional, universal life-type, participating, and financial guarantee contracts. It also defines when a contract with a reinsurer actually transfers insurance risk (significant insurance risk plus reasonable possibility of significant loss, 944-20-15-41) and prescribes recognition and with-and-without measurement for multiple-year retrospectively rated contracts. Contracts lacking indemnification or significant insurance risk are accounted for under the deposit method (340-30) or as investment contracts.
Key points (7)
- Insurance contracts must be classified as short-duration or long-duration depending on whether they are expected to remain in force for an extended period (944-20-15-2, 15-7, 15-10); examples include property/liability and credit life as short-duration and whole-life, guaranteed renewable term, endowment, annuity, and title insurance as long-duration (944-20-55-1, 55-3).
- Classification as an investment contract or insurance contract is made at contract inception and is not reassessed during the accumulation phase; if mortality/morbidity risk is nominal (insignificant amount or remote probability) the contract is an investment contract (944-20-15-20 through 15-21), and significance is tested by comparing the present value of expected excess payments to the present value of assessments plus expected investment margin under a range of scenarios (944-20-15-24 through 15-25).
- A contract with other-than-nominal mortality/morbidity risk whose fees or benefits are not fixed and guaranteed is a universal life-type contract (944-20-15-22, 15-26); participating or nonguaranteed-premium contracts that are in substance universal life-type are also within that model (944-20-15-27 through 15-30).
- Reinsurance of short-duration contracts qualifies for reinsurance accounting only if the reinsurer assumes significant insurance risk (amount and timing of its payments directly vary with claims settled) and it is reasonably possible the reinsurer will realize a significant loss (944-20-15-41), with a narrow 'substantially all' exception when only insignificant risk is retained by the ceding entity (944-20-15-53 through 15-54).
- Risk transfer is assessed at contract inception based on all cash flows between the parties discounted at a single reasonable rate (944-20-15-49, 15-51); any amendment beyond trivial changes requires reassessment, and a failed contract is accounted for as a deposit under Subtopic 340-30 (944-20-15-62 through 15-64, 944-20-15-55).
- For multiple-year retrospectively rated contracts, an asset or liability is recognized for obligatory retrospective rating provisions created by past experience, measured using a with-and-without method excluding future losses and future premiums payable regardless of experience (944-20-25-2, 25-4, 944-20-35-1, 35-3 through 35-4); deposit accounting may not be used to avoid loss recognition (944-20-25-3, 944-20-35-12).
- Reinsurance that legally replaces one insurer with another (assumption and novation) extinguishes the ceding entity's liability and requires derecognition of related assets and liabilities; otherwise the ceding entity keeps them on its balance sheet and must disclose that it is not relieved of its primary obligation (944-20-40-3 through 40-4, 944-20-50-3 through 50-4).
For students. This subtopic is the gateway to all of ASC 944: get the short- vs. long-duration and insurance- vs. investment-contract classification wrong and every downstream revenue, liability, and DAC conclusion is wrong. The most common misunderstanding is assuming anything labeled 'reinsurance' gets reinsurance accounting—substance controls, and without significant insurance risk plus a reasonable possibility of significant loss to the reinsurer, deposit accounting under 340-30 applies.
Machine-generated study aid for ASC 944-20. Check the source paragraphs below.
944-20-00Status
Source downloaded: .Record version 0ea86c8d4d7d. Effective date must be checked in the source.
944-20-05Overview and Background
Source downloaded: .Record version 4860d9c34438. Effective date must be checked in the source.
- aInsurance Activities
- bAcquisition Costs
- cClaim Costs and Liabilities for Future Policy Benefits
- dPolicyholder Dividends
- eSeparate Accounts.
- aGeneral
- bShort-Duration Contracts
- cLong-Duration Contracts
- dReinsurance Contracts
- eFinancial Guarantee Insurance Contracts.
Insurance Contracts
- aThe purchaser of an insurance contract makes an initial payment or deposit to the insurance entity in advance of the possible occurrence or discovery of an insured event.
- bWhen the insurance contract is made, the insurance entity ordinarily does not know if, how much, or when amounts will be paid under the contract.
- aThe death or disability of the insured
- bThe maturity of an endowment
- cThe incurrence of hospital or medical bills
- dThe destruction or damage of property and related deaths or injuries
- eDefects in, liens on, or challenges to the title to real estate
- fThe occurrence of a surety loss
- gBusiness interruption.
Statutory Accounting Practices
- aIf it wishes to depart from the prescribed statutory accounting practices
- bIf prescribed statutory accounting practices do not address the accounting for the transaction.
Short-Duration Contracts
Long-Duration Contracts
- aTraditional fixed and variable annuity and life insurance contracts
- bUniversal life-type contracts
- cNontraditional fixed and variable annuity and life insurance contracts
- dParticipating life insurance contracts
- eGroup participating pension contracts.
Traditional Fixed and Variable Annuity and Life Insurance Contracts
- aThe policyholder's payments, after deduction of specified sales and administrative charges, are used to purchase units of a separate investment account (a separate account).
- bThe policyholder directs the allocation of the account value among various investment options (typically various mutual funds). The policyholder bears the investment risk (that is, the account value is based entirely on the performance of the directed investments).
- cThe units may be surrendered for their current value in cash, although there is often a small surrender charge, or the units may be applied to purchase annuity income.
- dThe insurer guarantees mortality and maximum expense charges, and amounts are deducted periodically from the separate account to cover these charges.
- eDeferred annuity contracts typically provide a death benefit during the accumulation period under which the policyholder may receive the greater of the sum of premiums paid or the value of total units to the credit of the account at time of the policyholder's death.
Limited-Pay Insurance Contracts
Universal Life-Type Contracts
Nontraditional Fixed and Variable Annuity and Life Insurance Contracts
- aThe account value, as determined by the separate account assets
- bAll deposits that are made, plus 3 percent interest compounded annually.
- aMarket value annuities
- bMinimum guaranteed death benefit
- cMinimum guaranteed income benefit
- dNo-lapse guarantee
- eSales inducements to contract holders
- fOther features.
- aRoll-up death benefit. A death benefit equal to the total of deposits made to the contract less an adjustment for partial withdrawals, accumulated at a specified interest rate.
- bReset death benefit. A death benefit equal to the account balance on a specified anniversary date adjusted for deposits less partial withdrawals since the specified anniversary date.
- cRatchet death benefit. A death benefit equal to the highest account balance among prior specified anniversary dates adjusted for deposits less partial withdrawals since the specified anniversary date.
- aImmediate bonuses. In the case of the immediate bonus, the insurance entity is obligated to credit to the contract holder's account the sales inducement as a result of signing the contract. The contract holder account balance is increased for the full amount of the immediate bonus on the date that the bonus is contractually granted.
- bPersistency bonuses. A persistency bonus is credited to the contract holder account balance at the end of a specified period if the contract remains in force at that date.
- cEnhanced-crediting-rate bonuses. In an enhanced crediting rate sales inducement, the insurance entity offers customers a crediting rate for a stated period in excess of that currently being offered by the entity for other similar contracts. Pursuant to the contract, the enhanced crediting rate is applicable for a limited period of time, after which the rate is reset under the contractual provisions, typically at the discretion of the insurance entity.
Participating Life Insurance Contracts
Group Participating Pension Contracts
Reinsurance Contracts
Multiple-Year Retrospectively Rated Reinsurance Contract
- aChanges in the amount or timing of future contractual cash flows, including premium adjustments, settlement adjustments, or refunds to the ceding entity
- bChanges in the contract's future coverage.
Financial Guarantee Insurance Contracts
944-20-10Objectives
Source downloaded: .Record version 1ae652847566. Effective date must be checked in the source.
Reinsurance Contracts
Overall
Multiple-Year Retrospectively Rated Contracts
944-20-15Scope and Scope Exceptions
Source downloaded: .Record version a775426c09dd. Effective date must be checked in the source.
Overall Guidance
Other Considerations
- aMutual life insurance entities include assessment entities, fraternal benefit societies, and stock life insurance subsidiaries of mutual life insurance entities.
- bParticipating life insurance contracts denote those that have both of the following characteristics:
- 1They are long-duration participating contracts that are expected to pay dividends to policyholders based on actual experience of the insurance entity.
- 2Annual policyholder dividends are paid in a manner that both:
- aIdentifies divisible surplus
- bDistributes that surplus in approximately the same proportion as the contracts are considered to have contributed to divisible surplus (commonly referred to in actuarial literature as the contribution principle).
- a
- 1
Short-Duration Contracts
Overall Guidance
Instruments
- aThe contract provides insurance protection for a fixed period of short duration.
- bThe contract enables the insurer to cancel the contract or to adjust the provisions of the contract at the end of any contract period, such as adjusting the amount of premiums charged or coverage provided.
Long-Duration Contracts
Overall Guidance
Instruments
- aThe contract generally is not subject to unilateral changes in its provisions, such as a noncancelable or guaranteed renewable contract.
- bThe contract requires the performance of various functions and services (including insurance protection) for an extended period.
- aUniversal life-type contracts, that is, long-duration insurance contracts with terms that are not fixed and guaranteed
- bLimited-payment contracts, including limited-payment participating and limited-payment nonguaranteed-premium contracts that are not, in substance, universal life-type contracts
- cExcept as noted in paragraph 944-20-15-3, participating life insurance contracts
- dWhole-life contracts, that is, insurance contracts that may be kept in force for a person's entire life by paying one or more premiums
- eTerm life insurance contracts, that is, insurance contracts that provide a benefit if the insured dies within the period specified in the contract.
- aContracts offered through an insurance entity's separate accounts
- bVariable annuities with a minimum guaranteed death benefit or a guaranteed minimum accumulation benefit
- cVariable annuities with a guaranteed minimum income benefit
- dContracts providing multiple account balances
- eContracts with sales inducements.
Other Considerations
- aDistinguishing investment contracts from universal life-type insurance contracts
- bUniversal life-type contracts
- cEmbedded derivatives.
- aThe probability that life-contingent payments will be made is remote.
- bThe present value of the expected life-contingent payments relative to the present value of all expected payments under the contract is insignificant.
- aExcess payments. The present value of expected excess payments to be made under insurance benefit features—that is, insurance benefit amounts and related incremental claim adjustment expenses in excess of the account balances.
- bRevenue. The present value of all amounts expected to be assessed against the contract holder and the expected investment margin.
- aOne or more of the amounts assessed by the insurer against the policyholder—including amounts assessed for mortality coverage, contract administration, initiation, or surrender—are not fixed and guaranteed by the terms of the contract.
- bAmounts that accrue to the benefit of the policyholder—including interest accrued to policyholder balances—are not fixed and guaranteed by the terms of the contract.
- cPremiums may be varied by the policyholder within contract limits and without consent of the insurer.
- aThe policyholder may vary premium payments within contract limits and without consent of the insurer.
- bThe contract has a stated account balance that is credited with policyholder premiums and interest and against which assessments are made for contract administration, mortality coverage, initiation, or surrender, and any of the amounts assessed or credited are not fixed and guaranteed.
- cThe insurer expects that changes in any contract element will be based primarily on changes in interest rates or other market conditions rather than on the experience of a group of similar contracts or the entity as a whole.
Reinsurance Contracts
Overall Guidance
Entities
Instruments
- aAny transaction, regardless of its form, whose individual terms indemnify an insurer against loss or liability relating to insurance risk. That is, all contracts, including contracts that may not be structured or described as reinsurance, shall be accounted for as reinsurance if those conditions are met, including reinsurance contracts used to, in effect, sell a line of business by coinsuring all or substantially all of the risks related to the line.
- bAll contract amendments.
- aContracts that do not meet the conditions for reinsurance accounting
- bExcept as noted in the following paragraph, reinsurance assumed.
- aParagraphs , 944-20-15-46, 944-20-15-49, 944-20-15-51, 944-20-15-53, and provide guidance on indemnification against loss or liability relating to insurance risk.
- bParagraphs require certain disclosures.
Other Considerations
- a Limit the amount of insurance risk to which the reinsurer is subject (such as through experience refunds, cancellation provisions, adjustable features, or additions of profitable lines of business to the reinsurance contract)
- b Delay the timely reimbursement of claims by the reinsurer (such as through payment schedules or accumulating retentions from multiple years).
- a Significant insurance risk. The reinsurer assumes significant insurance risk under the reinsured portions of the underlying insurance contracts. Implicit in this condition is the requirement that both the amount and timing of the reinsurer's payments depend on and directly vary with the amount and timing of claims settled under the reinsured contracts.
- b Significant loss. It is reasonably possible that the reinsurer may realize a significant loss from the transaction.
- a Premiums are deferred over a period beyond the term of the underlying insurance contracts.
- b Losses are recognized in a different period than the period in which the event causing the loss takes place.
- c Both events (a) and (b) occur at different points in time.
- a The expected timing of payments to the reinsurer
- b The duration over which those cash flows are expected to be invested by the reinsurer.
- a The present value of all cash flows (determined as described in paragraph 944-20-15-49)
- b The present value of the amounts paid or deemed to have been paid to the reinsurer.
- a The net cash flows of the reinsurer under the reinsurance contract
- b The net cash flows of the ceding entity on the reinsured portions of the underlying insurance contracts.
- a The contract shall qualify as a short-duration contract under paragraph 944-20-15-7.
- b The contract shall not contain features that prevent the risk transfer criteria in this Subsection from being reasonably applied and those risk transfer criteria shall be met.
- c The ultimate premium expected to be paid or received under the contract shall be reasonably estimable and allocable in proportion to the reinsurance protection provided as required by paragraphs 944-605-25-2 and 944-605-35-8.
- a Replacing one assuming entity with another (including an affiliated entity)
- b Modifying the contract's limit, coverage, premium, commissions, or experience-related adjustable features.
Financial Guarantee Insurance Contracts
Overall Guidance
- aAn insurance contract that is similar to a financial guarantee insurance contract (for example, mortgage guaranty insurance and credit insurance on trade receivables)
- bA financial guarantee insurance contract accounted for as a derivative instrument within the scope of Subtopic 815-10.
Other Considerations
944-20-25Recognition
Source downloaded: .Record version e4bf310dcbec. Effective date must be checked in the source.
Short-Duration Contracts
Multiple-Year Retrospectively Rated Insurance Contracts
- aRecognize an asset to the extent that the insured has an obligation to pay cash (or other consideration) to the insurer that would not have been required absent experience under the contract
- bRecognize a liability to the extent that any cash (or other consideration) would be payable by the insurer to the insured based on experience to date under the contract.
Reinsurance Contracts
Multiple-Year Retrospectively Rated Contracts by Ceding and Assuming Entities
- aThe ceding entity shall recognize a liability and the assuming entity shall recognize an asset to the extent that the ceding entity has an obligation to pay cash (or other consideration) to the reinsurer that would not have been required absent experience under the contract (for example, payments that would not have been required if losses had not been experienced).
- bThe ceding entity shall recognize an asset and the assuming entity shall recognize a liability to the extent that any cash (or other consideration) would be payable from the assuming entity to the ceding entity based on experience to date under the contract.
944-20-30Initial Measurement
Source downloaded: .Record version 0155f01b7f34. Effective date must be checked in the source.
Reinsurance Contracts
Multiple-Year Retrospectively Rated Contracts by Ceding and Assuming Entities
944-20-35Subsequent Measurement
Source downloaded: .Record version 2b5b64e8dc9e. Effective date must be checked in the source.
Short-Duration Contracts
Multiple-Year Retrospectively Rated Insurance Contracts
Reinsurance Contracts
Multiple-Year Retrospectively Rated Contracts by Ceding and Assuming Entities
- aChanges in coverage
- bLoss recognition
- cWith-and-without method
- dMultiple contingent contractual features
- ePayment for continuation of contract
- fContract cancellation.
- aThe contract remains in force.
- bThe ceding entity cancels before the end of the contract term.
Multiple-Year Retrospectively Rated Contract Terminated by the Ceding Entity
- aThe ceding entity could terminate the contract before the end of its term.
- bTermination would change the amounts paid—for example, if terminating the contract would cost less than continuing the contract in force.
- aIf a decision to terminate has been made, the measurement shall be based on an assumption of termination and experience to date.
- bIf a decision to terminate has not been made, the measurement shall be based on the lesser of the following:
- 1The total incremental cost that would be paid based on the with-and-without calculation assuming experience to date and assuming termination—that is, excluding the effects of future losses and future premiums that would have been paid regardless of experience to date
- 2The total incremental cost that would be paid based on the with-and-without calculation assuming experience to date and assuming no termination—that is, excluding the effects of future losses and future premiums that would have been paid regardless of experience to date.
- 1
- aThe total incremental cost that would be paid based on the with-and-without method assuming experience to date and assuming termination
- bThe total incremental cost that would be paid based on the with-and-without method assuming experience to date and assuming no termination.
944-20-40Derecognition
Source downloaded: .Record version 25e5258c0663. Effective date must be checked in the source.
Reinsurance Contracts
Multiple-Year Retrospectively Rated Contracts by Ceding and Assuming Entities
Payment from Continuation of Reinsurance Contract
Assumption Reinsurance
944-20-45Other Presentation Matters
Source downloaded: .Record version 15cbc8cff263. Effective date must be checked in the source.
Long-Duration Contracts
Statement of Earnings—Universal Life-Type Contracts
- aBenefit claims in excess of the related policyholder balances
- bExpenses of contract administration
- cInterest accrued to policyholders
- dAmortization of capitalized acquisition costs (see Subtopic 944-30).
- aPremiums collected—see paragraph 944-605-25-5
- bAmounts assessed for compensation—see paragraph 944-605-25-6
- cAmounts assessed against policyholders for initiation or front end fees—see paragraph 944-605-25-5
- dUnearned revenue—see paragraph 944-605-35-2
- eAmounts that may be assessed against policyholders in future periods—see paragraph 944-40-30-17
- fCash values—see paragraph 944-40-30-18.
944-20-50Disclosure
Source downloaded: .Record version 8dfcd6636d12. Effective date must be checked in the source.
Long-Duration Contracts
Limited-Payment and Universal Life-Type Contracts
Certain Participating Life Insurance Contracts
Reinsurance Contracts
Financial Guarantee Insurance Contracts
944-20-55Implementation Guidance and Illustrations
Source downloaded: .Record version 2e94b5c26e6d. Effective date must be checked in the source.
Short-Duration Contracts
Implementation Guidance
- aMost property and liability insurance contracts
- bCertain term life insurance contracts, such as credit life insurance.
Long-Duration Contracts
- aWhole-life contracts
- bGuaranteed renewable term life contracts
- c
- dAnnuity contracts
- eTitle insurance contracts.
Reinsurance Contracts
Illustrations
- aThe retrospectively rated contract reinsures risks arising from short-duration contracts.
- bThe three-year contract prohibits cancellation during the contract period.
- cCash settlement is required upon termination of the contract.
- dThe contract provides for deposit premiums of $1.00 per year for $6.00 of coverage in excess of a stipulated retention.
- eCoverage is limited to one catastrophic event each year (that is, the ceding entity will not collect more than $6.00 per year from the reinsurer).
- fIf one or more losses occur, the ceding entity owes the reinsurer a single premium adjustment of $4.00 spread proportionately over the remaining contract term.
- gIf the ceding entity incurs a loss of $6.00 in the first year, the results in the fund balance will be negative $5.00 ($1.00 of premium to date less $6.00 of losses to date).
- hIn Years 2 and 3, the ceding entity must pay the assuming entity $3.00 each year ($1.00 of deposit premium and $2.00 of the premium adjustment).
- aAn additional $2.00 premium adjustment in each subsequent year that the contract is in force
- bIf the ceding entity terminates the contract before the end of the third year, 90% of any remaining premium adjustment.
944-20-65Transition and Open Effective Date Information
Source downloaded: .Record version d36380b4e2b0. Effective date must be checked in the source.
944-20-S00StatusSEC
Source downloaded: .Record version e71e27bbd00a. Effective date must be checked in the source.
| Paragraph | Action | Accounting Standards Update | Date |
| 944-20-S99-1 | Amended | Accounting Standards Update No. 2012-03 | 08/27/2012 |
| 944-20-S99-2 | Amended | Accounting Standards Update No. 2010-04 | 01/15/2010 |
944-20-S30Initial MeasurementSEC
Source downloaded: .Record version 69ab92097fe1. Effective date must be checked in the source.
Discounting Claims Liabilities Related to Short-Duration Contracts
944-20-S35Subsequent MeasurementSEC
Source downloaded: .Record version f011b1ac2bb4. Effective date must be checked in the source.
Discounting Claims Liabilities Related to Short-Duration Contracts
944-20-S50DisclosureSEC
Source downloaded: .Record version f7293834c5b5. Effective date must be checked in the source.
Present Value of Future Profits
944-20-S99SEC MaterialsSEC
Source downloaded: .Record version 404a8a58b38f. Effective date must be checked in the source.
SEC Staff Guidance
- Facts: A registrant which is an insurance company discounts certain unpaid claims liabilities related to short-duration FN9 insurance contracts for purposes of reporting to state regulatory authorities, using discount rates permitted or prescribed by those authorities ("statutory rates") which approximate 3 1/2 percent. The registrant follows the same practice in preparing its financial statements in accordance with GAAP. It proposes to change for GAAP purposes, to using a discount rate related to the historical yield on its investment portfolio ("investment related rate") which is represented to approximate 7 percent, and to account for the change as a change in accounting estimate, applying the investment related rate to claims settled in the current and subsequent years while the statutory rate would continue to be applied to claims settled in all prior years.
- FN9 The term "short-duration" refers to the period of coverage (see FASB ASC paragraph 944-20-15-7 (Financial Services—Insurance Topic), not the period that the liabilities are expected to be outstanding.
- Question 1: What is the staff's position with respect to discounting claims liabilities related to short-duration insurance contracts?
- Interpretive Response: The staff is aware of efforts by the accounting profession to assess the circumstances under which discounting may be appropriate in financial statements. Pending authoritative guidance resulting from those efforts however, the staff will raise no objection if a registrant follows a policy for GAAP reporting purposes of:
- Discounting liabilities for unpaid claims and claim adjustment expenses at the same rates that it uses for reporting to state regulatory authorities with respect to the same claims liabilities, or
- Discounting liabilities with respect to settled claims under the following circumstances:
- (1) The payment pattern and ultimate cost are fixed and determinable on an individual claim basis, and
- (2) The discount rate used is reasonable on the facts and circumstances applicable to the registrant at the time the claims are settled.
- Question 2: Does the staff agree with the registrant's proposal that the change from a statutory rate to an investment related rate be accounted for as a change in accounting estimate?
- Interpretive Response: No. The staff believes that such a change involves a change in the method of applying an accounting principle, i.e., the method of selecting the discount rate was changed. The staff therefore believes that the registrant should reflect the cumulative effect of the change in accounting by applying the new selection method retroactively to liabilities for claims settled in all prior years, in accordance with the requirements of FASB ASC Topic 250, Accounting Changes and Error Corrections. Initial adoption of discounting for GAAP purposes would be treated similarly. In either case, in addition to the disclosures required by FASB ASC Topic 250 concerning the change in accounting principle, a preferability letter from the registrant's independent accountant is required.
- The SEC staff will require registrants to provide the following disclosures about intangible assets arising from insurance contracts acquired in a business combination in filings with the Commission:
- 1. A description of the registrant's accounting policy
- 2. An analysis of the intangible assets arising from insurance contracts acquired in a business combination account for each year for which an income statement is presented—that analysis should include the intangible assets arising from insurance contracts acquired in a business combination balance at the beginning of the year, the amount of additions during the year arising from acquisitions of insurance companies, the amount of amortization during the year, the amount of any write-offs during the year due to impairment and how those write-offs were determined, and the balance at the end of the year
- 3. The estimated amount or percentage of the end-of-the-year balance of intangible assets arising from insurance contracts acquired in a business combination to be amortized during each of the next five years.
Related subtopics
- 605-944 Financial Services—InsuranceRevenue Recognition
- 815-944 Financial Services—InsuranceDerivatives and Hedging
- 825-944 Financial Services—InsuranceFinancial Instruments
- 405-944 Financial Services—InsuranceLiabilities
- 944-40 Claim Costs and Liabilities for Future Policy BenefitsFinancial Services—Insurance
- 944-30 Acquisition CostsFinancial Services—Insurance